Ok, I did some looking and thinking and my plan A right now is sassafras but I'll be working on a piece of osage as a plan B. Going for simple flatbow style with a bit of reflex and stiff handle with shelf. On the sassafras, I'm planning to go 2" wide or a little more with a slightly rounded belly to take some load off the back but I still think it will qualify as an american flatbow. I'm gonna chase rings and reduce to rough dimensions tomorrow, and then I'll bring them inside to stabilize for a couple of weeks.
Here's a picture of both staves,
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/689ff/689ff8239b1f09b1a21ff82b29da56703a239486" alt=""
and one of the ends.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/5ba84/5ba8418e9f77b323443cd5d506370d53a1e85a85" alt=""