Jamie, I tried the shorter one but found I was always having to pick it up after the strike. This one allows me to kinda keep the punch in place more often.
I wished I was better with antler punches, but I still struggle with that technique. Not sure if I am not making them right yet. I need to set with Marty R. sometime and get some pointers.
ordcorpdw, This technique is not a fail safe, just another way. If you are not use to free hand percussion then you might struggle.Also when you are driving flakes, it's easy to drive them into your hand, so be careful. The notches are about 1/16" on one end for shallow work and 1/8" for bigger removal.