Primitive Archer
Main Discussion Area => Bows => Topic started by: StickMan47 on March 25, 2013, 02:25:20 pm
-
Hi Guys. I was out yesterday riding down a logging road and came across some Magnolia trees that the timber company left on the ground. They are still green, been down maybe a month tops. I was just wondering if anyone on here has attempted making a bow out of this wood? I hauled 3 pieces of this stuff out and brought it home. I haven't split it into staves yet. The logs are from 4 to 6 inches around.
So do I go ahead and split them or save em for a different project? I looked up the SG in the TBB and all it said as for making bows was that it is diffuse porous and has a .48 SG. I know it isn't the best choice for a bow but hey it was free!
Sure wish the Osage staves I have were seasoned and ready to go.
-
I don't know but I have another magnolia you can have it you come cut it down. I may even help you cut it. >:D
-
I've been curious about this as well. Try it!
-
Magnolia in generally a soft, weak wood as far as bow woods go. It would probably make good arrows though.
-
Thanks Pat. That is what I was afraid of. I reckon I'll use em for somethin else. Too bad there ain't no Osage growin round here. Although I did come across a Black Cherry sapling growing in the woods behind the house here. It's got 3 good sized pieces growing outta the ground (about 2 1/2 inches around) that I'm seein a couple of potential bows in.
Marks, I appreciate the offer on your tree but I need to find some good bow wood. I have heard that magnolia makes a beautiful wood for woodworking. I got lots of woodworking wood piled up in the shed though.
Guess I'll keep lookin!
-
what color is it? It may make some nice fishing spools?
-
Stickman, can you really believe a guy with almost 20000 posts? >:D C'mon, you should try to make a bow out of it i nthe name of science!
-
Prarie, I never thought about making a fishing spool out of it. Thats a good idea though I'm not sure if I got all the tools for a project like that. Magnolia wood is real white, and having never worked with it I can't explain the grain pattern. My Dad does a lot of woodworking and he is the one who told me it is a pretty wood. But he don't make bows! lol.
Tim, yea you are right! Why should I listen to somebody who has made that many bows and bows of exceptional beauty at that! Just kidding Pat. I'm pretty hard headed but your advice is always welcomed. I may just see what I can do with one of them. Like you said "in the name of science". But I'm sure a true bowyer could do it more justice than me. I started an eastern red cedar bow that I haven't quite finished tillering yet. It is a beautiful piece of wood, imo, and is super knotty. I wish it was better for making bows with. I got 3 Osage staves that I can hardly wait to season so I can start on them!
Thanks again for all ya'lls advice. I know I don't post much on here but I reckon as I get more wood under my belt.... dang that didn't come out right at all.... ??? ..... as I build more bows I reckon I'll feel better bout givin advice.
-
I have a lot of southern magnolia growing in the woods where i'm at too. They're beautiful trees :) i'll let them stay that way. Lots of tuliptree too, i have some small logs of that. I cut down a small tree thinking it was maple (the leaves sorta look alike, same with sweetgum) till i looked at a budding leaf and was like, wait that's got four points that's not red maple x_x I think tuliptree is in the magnolia family? Though the lumber is sometimes sold as "poplar" Anyone try to make a bow from that? Or arrows? I would think it could make arrows if the grain was straight enough.
-
Yes, 'yellow poplar' or tuliptree (Liriodendron tulipifera) is in the magnolia family Magnoliaceae. It's probably the only member of this family with commercial wood? Not a particularly useful family, as far as the wood goes. Soft and pretty weak woods. There's soooo many better alternative bowwoods, that I wouldn't waste my time on any of its members...
-
Tulip poplar will make great arrows. I have some I got from Stringstretcher that he doweled last year.
-
Stickman I would go ahead and use tht magnolia to attempt a bow it would be a fun chellenge who cares if no one else has used it I would just try it
-
We had one that died a couple years back. When I cut it up the wood seemed spongy.
Cipriano
-
Magnolia cuts like butter with a chainsaw. My Magnolias are cut high enough to mow under them and they are a pain in the rear. In the fall they drop those big seed pods thingamajigers and are a pain to mow over. In the spring when your yard is good and pretty they decide to drop old leaves. I love em if they are grown down to the ground though.