Primitive Archer

Main Discussion Area => Bows => Topic started by: Kitsu on March 04, 2009, 04:46:10 pm

Title: How long is TOO long for a longbow? (and reason why i wont be on a while)
Post by: Kitsu on March 04, 2009, 04:46:10 pm
umm right now my bow is taller than me when i string for tillering it is this good or bad, it means it will be more flexible but will it not have as much power when i shorten, i love how it looks atm because longbows are supposed to be about as tall as the archer aye?

so leads me to my question, at 5 foot six, and my bow being almost 6 feet tall when strung, ima have to guess atm that its about 40#, however unable to test atm because my dad is getting fishing stuff for spring, therefor the scale is unavailable at this time (fishing scale is very useful because the hook grabs on to the string nicely, and when u pull it weighs AS you go :P) but still not tillered all the way but i want to know if i should shorten the ends a little bit because as of now its taller than me, any help would be appreciated

also im kinda grounded because my grades, been working on bow too much, i have study halls but even during them i still have leftover, and on top of that im a little forgetful and tend to leave stuff behind, or in locker etc, i wish i had a lil secretary or something, lol give them my stuff and they keep track, if i did ide have A's across, the work i DO do i get A+'s on them but half of them get misplaced so uhh yea, off topic but thats why i wont be here a while
Title: Re: How long is TOO long for a longbow? (and reason why i wont be on a while)
Post by: Cromm on March 04, 2009, 05:45:22 pm
Hi,

I was told a long time ago that a English Longbow should be a mimimum of one fist taller than the archer using it, so you should be ok. If you shorten the bow the lb will go up, as far as i know.
Thanks for your time.
Title: Re: How long is TOO long for a longbow? (and reason why i wont be on a while)
Post by: Kitsu on March 04, 2009, 05:46:59 pm
Hi,

I was told a long time ago that a English Longbow should be a mimimum of one fist taller than the archer using it, so you should be ok. If you shorten the bow the lb will go up, as far as i know.
Thanks for your time.

but i dont know if its the piece of wood taller than the archer or the overall bow itself, because so far not many people here have bows as tall as them
Title: Re: How long is TOO long for a longbow? (and reason why i wont be on a while)
Post by: Cromm on March 04, 2009, 05:50:57 pm
Well i'm 6 foot and i have 6 bows that are taller than me when strung up. One is about 7 1/2 foot tall when ready to shoot.
Thanks for your time.
Title: Re: How long is TOO long for a longbow? (and reason why i wont be on a while)
Post by: Hillbilly on March 04, 2009, 08:18:58 pm
I've made a few bows taller than me-there's no set length for a bow, just depends on what style you're shooting, the poundage, how long your draw length is, what kind of wood you're using, etc. A longer bow will usually draw smoother and be more accurate, in addition to putting less strain on the wood. It will also be more forgiving of tillering mistakes or flaws in the stave. Many of the old heavyweight warbows were seven feet long or more, and people then were probably shorter on average than now. A shorter bow can be more convenient to carry and use in thick cover or from a tree stand, but can also have problems with more set, stacking, or likelyhood of breaking. I would err on the side of too long instead of too short-I see many new bowyers who insist on trying to make really short bows and don't understand why they break or don't perform well.
Title: Re: How long is TOO long for a longbow? (and reason why i wont be on a while)
Post by: sailordad on March 04, 2009, 08:21:36 pm
i have a boo/ipe elb thats 72"ttt
just made 2hick board bows same length.
i am only 5'9.5",so all three are taler than me
Title: Re: How long is TOO long for a longbow? (and reason why i wont be on a while)
Post by: Hrothgar on March 04, 2009, 08:59:40 pm
I don't know if there is such a thing as too tall for a longbow (within reason). Take for example the japanese longbows which are over 7 feet. I have made 2 english longbows from ash, one is 73" ttt, the other is 73 1'2" ttt. I'm a shade under 6 feet, and if I ever make another elb it will be at least 73 1'2 ".
Title: Re: How long is TOO long for a longbow? (and reason why i wont be on a while)
Post by: Pat B on March 05, 2009, 12:56:05 am
Eventually you loose the mechanical advantage as the bow gets longer and the draw stays the same. If it gets long enough you could come to full draw and the tips wouldn't have moved at all. ;D
 Plus the excess weight would reduce recovery speed.
  With the English war bows the archer was pulling 30" to 32". Modern target and hunting bows are normally drawn to 28", or as Hillbilly's survey showed, its more like 26". A 7' bow being pulled 26" would be less effective than a 5 1/2' bow drawn 26".
  I'm working on a bow now that is my height(68"). I shot it yesterday for the first time and was pleased. Probably the use of the bow should be considered too.
Title: Re: How long is TOO long for a longbow? (and reason why i wont be on a while)
Post by: Kitsu on March 05, 2009, 10:02:52 am
as of now i was just trying to get one with some power, that doesn't end up blowing up, at this time i do not know what type of bow to actually consider it, but i plan on shortening eventually if it doesn't work out,

I'm looking for a target shooter as of this moment, but also a hunting bow possibly, (i don't want some crazy 90 lb bow at the moment, only because i want to get practice aiming, i COULD of had more power, yet i wanted to remove a few flaws. as of now it is quite smooth, however i kind of sanded handle down a little much, but its still a half inch thicker than thickest part of bow so I'm not MAJORLY worried, i  only wanted to figure out what was too long, after all, i wanted a balance of strength speed and flexibility here, not a full out brute. or a rubber band, (brute strength vs weak/flexible) i want something that could shoot better then the older boredom bows i made while this was seasoning,

 i care about looks too, but not too important , only because if i go hunting with my friends and they have nice store bought bows, they would prolly rub it in my face if mine looks bad in the face of theirs.
 
i know i have a little problem with rambling on like this, if i get a little off topic time to time forgive me,
Title: Re: How long is TOO long for a longbow? (and reason why i wont be on a while)
Post by: TRACY on March 05, 2009, 10:13:50 am
I work with a lot of students in your situation. Buckle down and get your grades back on track first and then build bows. Ask for help if you don't understand stuff and use all of the resources you have access too. If you have to set small goals and reward yourself for finishing something with bow time then do it. Good luck with both tasks!
Title: Re: How long is TOO long for a longbow? (and reason why i wont be on a while)
Post by: Pat B on March 05, 2009, 10:22:40 am
Make a bow that fits your stave and not the other way around!  Quit worring about how pretty it is and make it functional. You can always add make-up to pretty it up later.
   If you are worried about your friends ribbing you because they have pretty store bought bows you are going to have a hard time building a worthwhile bow. You have already defeated yourself.  Make the best bow you can and learn to shoot it well. You will be able to show off your bow with pride and rub it in there faces when you can do as well or better than they can. A bow is only a tool! What you do with the tool is the proof in the pudding.
   What is your draw length?  Draw weight? Do you have a pic of your stave? What wood is it?
Most improtant now is what Tracy said. School is #1!!! 8)
Title: Re: How long is TOO long for a longbow? (and reason why i wont be on a while)
Post by: Dane on March 05, 2009, 01:26:22 pm
Pat is right. I hate to sound like a nagging parent, but your most imporant job is school. Your future is really determined in large part by the opportunities you will have (and not have) based on today. I hated school, and really suffered for not doing my best back then.

You have tons of bows in your future, and like Tracy said, reward yourself for doing well with bowyery.

Dane
Title: Re: How long is TOO long for a longbow? (and reason why i wont be on a while)
Post by: nickf on March 05, 2009, 06:18:50 pm
bus up to 8feet were used, and you may go alot longer, if the tiller and drawlength/weigth are customed for this bow.
6feet should work. We're probably in a similar situation, at this moment i'm more or less pumping out bows, and not doing much for school :p

Nick
Title: Re: How long is TOO long for a longbow? (and reason why i wont be on a while)
Post by: Kitsu on March 05, 2009, 09:00:49 pm
I work with a lot of students in your situation. Buckle down and get your grades back on track first and then build bows. Ask for help if you don't understand stuff and use all of the resources you have access too. If you have to set small goals and reward yourself for finishing something with bow time then do it. Good luck with both tasks!

i found out i have a big shot atm, the retake of my math test is going to bring my grade to a B or higher, and my english teacher expects me to find 20 words i DONT know (self improvement project) however when there is a word i dont know, its defined in side notes and she wont allow that, well, ill still get a B in hers too IF i can get some help, i need a quote and sources and unfortunately, all my books are in a storage atm, and my schoolbooks dont really have many words i dont know (ive learned biology before, learned global studies before, so i know thiis stuff, however i moved from a different state, and they didnt transfer my credits and stuff, that and its not regents coarse or whatever, but im not trying to make excuses, i know im not a human dictionary, but its hard to find words i dont know in school, and even harder to find them in the non existent books in my room >.>
Title: Re: How long is TOO long for a longbow? (and reason why i wont be on a while)
Post by: Dane on March 05, 2009, 09:20:18 pm
Josh, at the risk of sounding obvious, you have the Internet. But don't cheat or anything like that.

One of the richest sources of strange and wonderful words is the Mervyn Peake Gormenghast novels, Titus Groan, Ghormenghast, and Titus Alone. You can find them at the library, or through your school's interlibrary loan system. The books are not easy, but use complex language in a way that I think has not been duplicated, Peake was such a unique stylist and fantasist. If you like Lord of the Rings, you may like Peake. You will get major points by any English teacher for even knowing about his work. My wife teaches Shakespear at a local colllege, and even she had not heard about his works (UCLA, shame on you, lol). Peake was a British author and illustrator who died tragically in 1968 from Parkison's Disease.

The Oxford English Dictionary (known as the OED) is another amazing source of new words. And if you have the Alice in Wonderland books around, there is some amazing use of language there too. Treacle is one word I love from the Alice books.

I hope that helps you a bit,

Dane

Title: Re: How long is TOO long for a longbow? (and reason why i wont be on a while)
Post by: Loki on March 06, 2009, 09:21:25 am
What do you call Treacle in America Dane?
Try your teacher out on some Northern English words  ;D we sound differnt to those southern folks,if i wrote like a speak you wouldnt understand a word of it:)
http://www.northeastengland.talktalk.net/GeordieDictionary.htm

Here's three English words to get you started,it shouldnt be hard to find twenty!
Bamboozle
http://www.askoxford.com/concise_oed/bamboozle?view=uk
Fettle
http://www.askoxford.com/results/?view=dev_dict&field-12668446=fettle&branch=13842570&textsearchtype=exact&sortorder=score%2Cname
Balderdash
http://www.askoxford.com/results/?view=dev_dict&field-12668446=balderdash&branch=13842570&textsearchtype=exact&sortorder=score%2Cname


One of my Longbows is 74" long with a 32" draw,i'm 5'8".
Title: Re: How long is TOO long for a longbow? (and reason why i wont be on a while)
Post by: Dane on March 06, 2009, 11:29:10 am
Mollases, Andy. Nice and sweet and sticky.

Now, to use those words in a sentence. "Balderdash! Don't even try to bamboozle me, laddie, I'm in a fine fettle, and won't let your cheap, penny-ante tricks ruin my day."

Dane
Title: Re: How long is TOO long for a longbow? (and reason why i wont be on a while)
Post by: Kitsu on March 06, 2009, 03:00:15 pm
Mollases, Andy. Nice and sweet and sticky.

Now, to use those words in a sentence. "Balderdash! Don't even try to bamboozle me, laddie, I'm in a fine fettle, and won't let your cheap, penny-ante tricks ruin my day."

Dane

o.o *is extremely confused*



I MAY be going to home depot today, my old knife broke and im in need of a new one, i used it for shaping and it took some damage time to time, used dull side as scraper, sharp side for numerous purposes, it gave way and the handle broke, i am hoping it can make a beastly arrowhead plan on buying a dowel for it :P ill keep you posted on how it goes,

as for now i have $20 that should be enough for some spar urethane some sandpaper and a cheap new knife, that and hopefully i may get a little early birthday presents from parents, im turning 16 i dont care about a car atm, wouldnt get to drive it regardless anyway,

 i just want to get this a little thinner, its ALMOST even at bending but i crave perfection its not hard to pull back or anything though, im afraid to go further but im going to sand it even rather then focus my efforts into   taking off so little, this has been going a while but i only have one shot with this bow, i have a bunch of logs waiting to be split into staves but my grandma hid my hatchet from me (saying i should use the huge thick one with the 5 lb blade... its a pain to lift, and when i split i lift both and hit against ground, whereas, with a hatchet i will just hammer it in and split it like that
Title: Re: How long is TOO long for a longbow? (and reason why i wont be on a while)
Post by: Justin Snyder on March 06, 2009, 05:27:57 pm
You dont have to loose performance just because you make it longer.  If you leave a long non bending section in the middle you could go out to some serious lengths without adding weight to the "working limb."   :o
Title: Re: How long is TOO long for a longbow? (and reason why i wont be on a while)
Post by: OldBow on March 06, 2009, 11:17:49 pm
I am an old biology teacher. I taught wildlife biology, etc.here in Montana. Wish i knew about bows back then. You could have worked on a coop project with the woods classes, art, history, biology, received credit, and worked in my classroom!!
Title: Re: How long is TOO long for a longbow? (and reason why i wont be on a while)
Post by: Kitsu on March 08, 2009, 05:58:35 pm
I am an old biology teacher. I taught wildlife biology, etc.here in Montana. Wish i knew about bows back then. You could have worked on a coop project with the woods classes, art, history, biology, received credit, and worked in my classroom!!

yeah... too bad bows are Weapons :P otherwise that would work out nice,

 well, today i got some Minwax poly-stain and i am hoping it is as good as the store claims it to be... its polyurethane and a stain in one, but ummm... its taking a while to dry, been like 2 hours and its still hella shiney and hella wet, (i even applied thin...) it is prolly cause its kinda cold atm, it went from 60s and 70s and its 40 again, i get everything setup for spring and bam, slapped again by natures fury :P

and for just drying something, do i seal the ends with the poly FIRST, or do i wait til i finish?